Announcing a Return to our Roots: The All-New Bitcoin Magazine

BitBills’s Patent- Will Patents Hinder Bitcoin’s Evolution?


         BitBills’s Patent- Will Patents Hinder Bitcoin’s Evolution?

What would an approved patent for a physical Bitcoin mean for the Bitcoin community? Douglas Feigelson, the founder of BitBills, filed a patent with the United States Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) on December 23, 2011. Just last Saturday, June 27, 2013, the USPTO processed Feigelson’s application and entitled the application for a patent as, “Creating and Using Digital Currency.” There is much concern within the Bitcoin community that such a patent, if approved, could potentially restrict further hardware Bitcoin wallet development.  “Let’s Talk Bitcoin,” highlighted the connection between the patent and BitBills’s cold storage concept.  Additionally, we can question what the further implications of a patent description including the world, “Bitcoin” might mean.  Currently, the Bitcoin community is unique and thriving due to an openness to ingenuity, development of new products and the betterment of existing products and Bitcoin accessories.

What are BitBills?

On May 9, 2011, the first BitBill was launched. BitBills preceded Casascius coins as the first physical form of Bitcoins. As plastic cards, BitBills store Bitcoin and provide individuals with an opportunity to not only store Bitcoins but also trade Bitcoins.  Along with each BitBill, a new Bitcoin address is created to provide a user a place to store Bitcoins and also a QR code to receive and transfer Bitcoins.  As security is key for BitBills and other physical manifestations of the Bitcoin currency, Bitbills are secured through anti-counterfeiting and tamper-evidence.  As each BitBill contains a security hologram and an embedded private key, it is next to impossible to counterfeit a BitBill.

Protection of Ingenuity is Key

Are BitBills an asset to the Bitcoin community? YES! Yet, BitBills are not significant enough to merit a compromise of one of the founding principles surrounding the Bitcoin community: INGENUITY. As Feigelson took the step to request a patent for his BitBills, several in the Bitcoin community are concerned about what this might mean for future opportunities to readily update and improve hardware wallets. With a USPTO stamp of approval on Feigelson’s patent application, members of the Bitcoin community will be restricted in some capacities of improving Feigelson’s design and also building off of BitBills to develop an even more secure and efficient wallet.

Bitcoin has thrived in part due to the limited government involvement to date in the Bitcoin currency and hardware involving Bitcoin. Feigelson’s request for a patent is one of the first steps to bring the United States’s Federal Government into the Bitcoin space. There will most likely come a time when the US Federal Government will take larger steps to get involved and regulate the Bitcoin currency, but the Bitcoin community would not want such involvement to take place prematurely.

Always be Mindful of Unintended Consequences

Certainly, Feigelson’s development of BitBills has worked for the betterment of the Bitcoin community. However, prior to proactively involving the US Federal Government in the Bitcoin space, he should understand the several unintended consequences of such a step. Protecting one’s work definitely makes sense, but one should be mindful that such actions may deter development and growth of a currently flourishing Bitcoin community. What will come of Feigelson’s patent request?  Since this affects everyone in the community, make your voice heard.   Do you agree with Douglas Feigelson’s attempt to secure a patent for BitBills?

Make your voice heard!  We do not know, but we can hope that the free market, limited government, ingenuity  and promoting spirit of the Bitcoin community will not be squelched.


Ten Years Later, a Reflection on Bitcoin’s Genesis and Satoshi’s Timing

Rather than focusing simply on what the genesis block is, today is a day to reflect on what the genesis block represents.

Colin Harper

Op Ed: From Gray To Black and White: Traditional Regulations Come to Crypto

For the crypto industry, recent developments — at both the federal and international levels — signal that the time for plausible deniability or unregulated freedom is coming to an end and more traditional regulations are moving to the forefront.

Courtney Rogers Perrin and Joshua Lewis

Bitcoin Price Analysis: Blowing Through Support Levels on the Way to $3,000

Bitcoin continues to tumble lower and lower as it struggles to claim any footing in the market. It’s down almost 50% in three weeks and it’s showing very little sign of stopping. It’s currently clutching onto the $3,500 values but it doesn’t look like it can hold on much longer.

Bitcoin Schmitcoin

Op Ed: SEC’s Latest Declaration Creates Legal Minefield for Digital Assets

This broad, authoritative declaration is not unexpected, as, to date, the SEC has stated that all digital assets — regardless of whether they function as alt coins or utility tokens — are securities at least initially and, thus, subject to its jurisdiction.

Huhnsik Chung and Nicholas Secara